Tolle legeBible study notes

← All notes

Ecclesiastes · · 3 min read

Ecclesiastes, chapter by chapter, with fifteen voices

The whole book in one chart, fifteen Christian readers from Origen to Tremper Longman, the commentaries and sermons that shaped it, and seven big questions.

Open the interactive walkthrough Ecclesiastes: an interactive walkthrough A chart of the whole book, fifteen voices through history, the commentaries and sermons, and the big questions.

Ecclesiastes is twelve chapters that keep circling one word, hevel: breath, vapor, the thing the King James Version calls “vanity.” It turns up 38 times in 222 verses, beside 29 uses of “under the sun” and seven refrains that tell the reader to eat, drink and enjoy their work. The interactive walkthrough that goes with this note follows that shape through the book, then puts fifteen Christian readers from eighteen centuries beside it.

What is in the walkthrough

  • Walkthrough. A chart of the whole book: hevel counts, the joy refrains (Whybray’s seven) and where the narrator’s voice frames the Teacher. Choose a chapter’s bar, or use the arrow keys, to read a summary of that chapter and a short “How it’s been read” box.
  • Voices through history. Fifteen readers, from Origen, Gregory of Nyssa and Jerome through Luther, Bunyan and Matthew Henry to Delitzsch, Bonhoeffer, Ellul and Tremper Longman III. Filter them by how they read the book, then choose a name to see their background, their take and the conclusion they drew. Each person links back to the chapters where they appear.
  • Commentaries & sermons. The homily cycles, commentaries, sermon series and books that shaped how the church reads Ecclesiastes. Filter by era or kind, or search by author, title or idea.
  • The big questions. Seven arguments the book has started (who wrote it and when, why it is in the Bible, what hevel means, pessimist or preacher of joy, the afterlife, despising or receiving the world, and where it points in the Christian Bible) and where the main voices land.

How far to trust the quotations

A few claims were spot-checked against the sources below. The rest of the content comes from the model’s own knowledge and was not checked source by source, so check anything you plan to cite.

  • Marked “In their words”: the Thomas à Kempis, Bunyan and Delitzsch lines are standard quotations, but they were not looked up. Gregory of Nyssa’s “obols” line matches the published translations found online, which vary. Luther’s “fleeing the world” line comes from an online translation that could not be matched against the standard English edition (Luther’s Works). The Augustine and Thomas Boston lines are from memory and were not checked; translations of Augustine vary.
  • Marked “In brief”: these are summaries, not quotations.
  • Bonhoeffer: sources disagree on the date (17 or 19 December 1943) and on who the letter was to, so the walkthrough just says “Advent 1943.”
  • Left out: a well-known Delitzsch phrase calling the book “the Song of Songs of the fear of God,” because it could not be confirmed that he wrote it, and a three-part scheme of “vanity” sometimes credited to Bonaventure, for the same reason.

Where to start reading

For the history of interpretation, Eric Christianson’s Ecclesiastes Through the Centuries and the Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture volume (Old Testament IX). For devotional reading, Derek Kidner’s short commentary and Jacques Ellul’s Reason for Being.

Sources checked